HavenFans.co.uk - The Unofficial Whitehaven RLFC Forum

Challenge Cup 2nd Round Draw

Offline cbandg01

  • Top Try Scorer
  • ******
    • Posts: 3103
  • Let's play to our strengths to create problems
Reply #15 on: 14 Feb 2015, 05:53:01 pm
Provided the RFL are going to proactively involved in vetting EVERYONES player list before matches then OK, this is a forwards step.

HOWEVER, I read the rules quite thoroughly last year, and it CLEARLY said that the clubs were ultimately responsible for ensuring all players involved were legally registered to play.

Although the rules said that however, the RFL obviously  didn't apply the rules last season and by not doing so let Batley and Donny off at the expense of poor old Keighley.

Why Keighley didn't take the RFL on and fight a case against them I'll never know, and on a wider scale it was an ideal opportunity for none SL clubs to collectively take on the RFL and show that they had some teeth, and the stomach for a fight when RFL decisions disadvantaged or disregarded them.


Offline chris robinson

  • Academy Star
  • **
    • Posts: 124
Reply #16 on: 14 Feb 2015, 07:42:26 pm
The RFL are not proactive, ie; they only react when an incident occurs, and usually brought to their attention by either an aggrieved party, or an outsider merely questioning the rules. With regards to Batley & Doncaster, they couldn't actually do anything as they had allowed the same event to happen the year before, and subsequently hadn't put into legislation rules to prevent it. Consequently if Keighly had taken the RFL to court they would have lost as a precedent had already been set, and so any challenge would have been thrown out of court. What is alarming, is the fact that I do not believe that that the RFL have amended the Constitution or rules of the game to cover the point in question, therefore leaving it open to any team to abuse the rules knowing that if push comes to shove they cannot be punished. It is easier to do it in the Challenge Cup preliminary rounds as the RFL know that any amateur club hans't got the finances or clout to take them on. Consequently, at tha moment there is a big devide on how professional clubs are dealt with under the rules of the game, compared to the amateurs. Even more concerning is that there appears to also be a devide in how SL Clubs are dealt with, for identical offences, compared to Championship Clubs.

Don't hold your breath for any change in the near future.