HavenFans.co.uk - The Unofficial Whitehaven RLFC Forum

CRAIG MCAVOY & MATTY DALE

Offline whitehavenRLforever

  • Top Try Scorer
  • ******
    • Posts: 4148
Reply #15 on: 21 Jun 2007, 10:43:27 pm
its got to be wrong!!!
shouldnt matter when u sign a player, providing they havent played for anyone else in the competition this season

so that would make matty ok and surely hovisroyd should be cup tied having played in group stages for donny!

Its  a  tricky  one  this.  I  can  understand  Dale  not  being allowed  to  play  as  whats  stopping  all  the  sides  that  reach  the  semi's  suddenly  recruiting  SL  players.

As  for  Holroyd  by  rights  he  should be  ineligible  as  he  played  for  Donny  in  the  NRC  but  because  they  went  into  CVA  all  that  becomes  null  and void.

Quite  frankly  it  stinks  but  what can  you  do. ??? 


Offline LeeF

  • First Team Regular
  • ****
    • Posts: 1578
Reply #16 on: 22 Jun 2007, 06:05:09 am
its got to be wrong!!!
shouldnt matter when u sign a player, providing they havent played for anyone else in the competition this season

so that would make matty ok and surely hovisroyd should be cup tied having played in group stages for donny!

Its  a  tricky  one  this.  I  can  understand  Dale  not  being allowed  to  play  as  whats  stopping  all  the  sides  that  reach  the  semi's  suddenly  recruiting  SL  players.

As  for  Holroyd  by  rights  he  should be  ineligible  as  he  played  for  Donny  in  the  NRC  but  because  they  went  into  CVA  all  that  becomes  null  and void.

Quite  frankly  it  stinks  but  what can  you  do. ??? 

It's nothing to do with Donny going into a CVA - it's just the rules and didn't we benefit when we signed Carl Sice a few years back?