we all know who the best hooker at the club is and his name is CARL SICE
i am sorry but after reading all the last 3 forum threads this has finally got to me!!
carl sice is not the best hooker at the club, but he is one of the best players!!
carl sice is not a good passer off the ball, FACT, and he does not create alot of little plays around the ruck for our bigger forwards to gain more ground and get a roll on like matty and lester do. this is a hookers job, a hooker is a play maker to the forwards, and a ball distributor to the 6&7 for the outside backs to work off. at playing this role sice is not in the same league as lester matty or smith! so get ur facts right!! and put your dummy back in!!!
however.........
i agree that sice is an excellent player and the one single player who i would look to to win us a match from the bench, he is an excellent player and can pull us out the S**** from time to time! which is why he is worth his place in the 17 every week, but as an impact player, against tiered defences which make him more efective at beating a man and making a break!
summary;
sice excellent impact player!!
not the best all round hooker in the club!!